Why Email Marketing Has Better ROI Than Social Media

Have you ever wondered why some businesses seem to be crushing it with their digital marketing efforts while others struggle to get noticed? Well, a big part of the secret sauce lies in the magic of email marketing. Email marketing is the heavy hitter in the world of digital marketing, packing a punch that consistently delivers high ROI and unrivaled personalized engagement.

But many businesses make the mistake of ignoring email marketing and investing their time and money in social media. It’s understandable – social media appears swift, enjoyable, and seemingly offers a speedier route to capture and convert potential buyers. But does this assumption hold water?

As we dig deeper, let’s explore two key players. Email marketing is that reliable friend, sending targeted messages right to inboxes. On the flip side, social media’s the bustling party where connections are made through posts, photos, and videos. And speaking of connections, let’s shift our focus to a crucial concept in the marketing world – ROI, or “Return on Investment.”

image of a lemonade stand

Understanding Email Marketing ROI

Alright, let’s dive into the money talk, but don’t worry, we’ll keep it super simple. We’re going to talk about ROI – Return on Investment – and why it’s like the superstar stat in the world of marketing.

So, imagine you’re running a lemonade stand. You invest $20 in lemons, sugar, and cups, and after a day of selling, you’ve made $100. Your ROI would be (Profit – Investment) / Investment. In this case, it’s ($100 – $20) / $20, which equals 4. That’s an ROI of 4 or 400%. Basically, for every dollar you invested, you got back four. Not too shabby, right?

Now, apply this concept to email marketing. It’s like sending out those email campaigns and then counting up the dough they bring in compared to what you spent on them. If you spent $500 on crafting and sending emails, but they brought in $3000 in sales, your ROI would be ($3000 – $500) / $500, which equals 5. That’s an ROI of 5 or 500%. For every dollar you put in, you got back five. Sweet deal!

But here’s an even more impressive statistic: on average, for every $1 invested in email marketing, businesses generate $42 in returns, resulting in an astounding ROI of 4200%.

Email marketing’s like a little money-making machine that keeps churning out results!

Image of a cell phone taking a pacture

Analyzing Social Media Marketing ROI

Now, let’s shift our focus to another player in the digital marketing game – social media!

Imagine this: you’re a small bakery, tantalizing Instagram users with mouthwatering cupcake pics. You even invest some funds to give those posts a boost and reach a wider audience. But, gauging the ROI of social media isn’t as simple as counting the coins in your piggy bank. Let’s be real; not every thumbs-up or heart emoji translates directly to cold, hard cash. Someone might be showering love on your cupcake pic but never really make their way to your bakery.

And the challenges don’t stop there. You might be scratching your head about which of those Instagram posts or ads actually led someone to buy your delectable treats. Plus, the tricky part is that people might be seeing your posts on different gadgets or platforms, making it a puzzle to track their path to purchase. And remember, some social media benefits, like building brand awareness or nurturing customer loyalty, don’t always immediately convert into dollars. It’s like trying to hold onto a handful of water.

And marketing studies show that for every $1 you spend on social media, you’ll get a return of $2.80 or 280%. When you compare email marketing’s average of 4200% ROI, to social media’s average of for social media’s average of 280%, it’s easy to see the appeal of email marketing.

cartoon image of people reading email and commenting on social media

Factors Contributing to Email Marketing’s Superior ROI

Alright, let’s get into the juicy stuff – why email marketing is like the MVP when it comes to that sweet, sweet ROI.

First up, let’s talk about the way email marketing swoops in with targeted audience engagement. Email lets you customize content like a champ. Remember those cupcake pics from the bakery we talked about earlier? Well, if I love chocolate and you’re all about vanilla, you’d probably click on different cupcake offers, right? Email lets you send stuff that matches people’s tastes, increasing the chances they’ll bite.

Now, here’s a biggie – control, and ownership of subscriber data. With email marketing, you’re the boss of your own list. You’re not at the mercy of those tricky social media algorithms that seem to change their minds every other day. And you don’t lose your subscriber information if one of your social media accounts goes down – which can sometimes take months to reactivate.

And the cherry on top? Direct and personal communication. Email lets you slide into your customers’ inboxes like a friendly neighbor dropping by for a chat. It’s private and feels less like an ad and more like a conversation. And guess what? People actually open those emails. We’re talking about way higher open rates and click-through rates compared to those posts you put up on social media.

image of social media icons

Social Media’s Role in the Marketing Mix

Let’s shift gears a bit and talk about the dynamic duo of email marketing and social media. The two can work together like peanut butter and jelly, making your marketing efforts even more delicious.

First off, social media isn’t the enemy here; it’s like that cool sidekick that can boost your email game. Imagine you’ve just sent out an awesome newsletter announcing a big sale. Now, hop on social media and shout it from the rooftops! Use those eye-catching visuals, catchy captions, and maybe even a swipe-up link to your website. It’s like turning up the volume on your message, reaching even more ears (or in this case, eyes).

And hey, social media’s got its own superpowers, too – like building brand awareness and customer engagement. It’s where you can show off your personality, share behind-the-scenes glimpses, and even crack a few jokes. It’s all about creating that connection with your audience, so when they get your email in their inbox, they’re like, “Hey, I know these guys!”

But here’s where the magic happens integrating social media with email marketing for a seamless strategy. Picture this – you post a teaser about an exciting announcement on Instagram, like a new product launch. People are intrigued, and you tell them, “Hey, sign up for our newsletter to be the first to know!” Bam! You just directed them from social media to your email list, getting them into your marketing funnel.

And it works the other way around too. You send an email with a special offer, and you sprinkle a little social media love by saying, “Tag a friend who needs this!” Now your subscribers are sharing your stuff, and you’re tapping into their networks. It’s like a beautiful cycle of engagement.

Email marketing and social media aren’t competitors; they’re partners in crime. They complement each other, boost each other’s strengths, and create a powerhouse strategy that covers all the bases.

image of a scale comparing the importance of social media channels

Balancing Email Marketing and Social Media: A Winning Strategy

So, as you navigate the ever-evolving world of marketing, remember this: it’s not about choosing sides; it’s about creating a symphony of strategies that work together harmoniously. Prioritize email marketing for its ROI brilliance, and let social media add that extra flair to your performance. Your audience is out there, waiting to groove to your tune.

Need a little help getting started with email marketing? Or need a strategy to integrate your email marketing and social media? Schedule a conversation to find out how to leverage email marketing and social media for your business!

Jumpstart Your Digital Marketing

Schedule an appointment with Jonathan Christian

Get up to $15k in grants and $100k in loans to accelerate your digital adoption plan.

Learn More

How To Thrive During A Recession Using Digital Marketing

Low-cost digital marketing strategies to help your business thrive during a recession.


Lets Connect:

Price Based Country test mode enabled for testing United States (US). You should do tests on private browsing mode. Browse in private with Firefox, Chrome and Safari